By Donald Grove, Contributing Editor, The Casey Report
Implementation of the infamous Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA) got underway in earnest on July 1, 2014. A cacophony of protests and warnings could be heard as that date approached, and it has only grown louder as more and more people realize how startlingly draconian and wrongheaded this legislation is.
Even if one believes that the real objective behind FATCA is, as professed, to snag wealthy overseas tax cheats, it isn’t hard to see that the collateral damage far exceeds any conceivable benefit. Any additional tax revenue will be dwarfed by compliance costs, lost foreign investment, overseas financial institutions refusing to do business with Americans, and the alarming specter of more and more Americans renouncing their citizenship.
Road Trip
Jim Bopp, a serially successful Supreme Court litigator, and Mike Lee, Republican Senator from Utah, have taken their battle against FATCA on the road. Mike Lee is a member of the Senate Judiciary Committee who stepped onto the national stage with his rebuttal to President Obama’s State of the Union address in January this year. Senator Lee will explain how FATCA can be attacked legislatively.
As I write, they are in Paris addressing attendees of an event sponsored by the Association of Americans Resident Overseas (AARO) and Republicans Overseas. Additional stops are planned for London, Frankfort, Geneva, and Luxembourg. The tour may even extend to Asia.
Jim Bopp is preparing to challenge the constitutionality of FATCA in the Supreme Court and will be lining up plaintiffs for that court case during this tour. The AARO told its members that the pair will discuss the court challenge and explain why FATCA is “an invasion of privacy, an overstepping of authority on the part of the Treasury Department, and a tool for ‘cruel and unusual punishment.’” Their tour will build support for FATCA reform among 7.6 million Americans who live and work overseas but mostly do not vote in US elections. Organizers hope to register and get ballots to this huge block of voters—equivalent to the 13th-largest state.
Unwilling Participants
It’s easy to understand why foreign banks are closing Americans’ accounts and refusing to open new ones: FATCA basically turns them into snitches for the IRS. Overseas Americans are treated like tax evaders—guilty until proven innocent. Foreign financial institutions (FFIs) are required to perform “due diligence” on “suspicious” customers, including flagging those who open accounts using foreign passports but are US citizens or permanent residents of the US. Banks that are not sufficiently attentive or fail to report suspicious customers risk being deemed “negligent” by the IRS and may be sanctioned.
The US Treasury Department seems quite proud of the fact that foreign banks are complying with FATCA. That compliance is not willing, however. The banks really have no choice. US correspondent banks in New York have been told not to provide correspondent services to foreign banks that don’t comply with FATCA. To tighten the noose, US banks have also been told not to do business with any foreign banks that assist banks that are not compliant. Thus, a compliant FFI that assists a noncompliant FFI is shunned by US correspondent banks on which it relies to process its own payments.
Closing the Gates
The poor, if they want to slip away from the clutches of the US before becoming wealthy, have a relatively easy time of it. It is not as easy for the wealthy to escape. The IRS imposes a tax on unrealized capital gains of both citizens renouncing their citizenship and of noncitizen green card holders who have been allowed to live and work in the US. Under Internal Revenue Code § 877A, the property of “covered expatriates” is taxed at 15% on a mark-to-market basis on the day before expatriation.
Senators Chuck Schumer (D-NY) and Bob Casey Jr. (D-PA) have more than once tried to enact the Ex-PATRIOT Act (Expatriation Prevention by Abolishing Tax-Related Incentives for Offshore Tenancy). Their bill would have doubled the tax on Americans leaving the US for tax reasons to 30%. These efforts to keep money from leaving our shores are reminiscent of exit taxes imposed on Jews leaving Nazi Germany in the 1930s and by Rhodesia in the 1970s. Grover Norquist, president of Americans for Tax Reform, suggested that Schumer “probably just plagiarized it and translated it from the original German.”
Since 1996 American citizens who renounced their citizenship to avoid taxes could be denied a visa to return to the US. The Ex-PATRIOT Act would have replaced that 1996 Reed Amendment with its own provision denying admission to “specified expatriates” and shifting jurisdiction from the Attorney General to Treasury and Homeland Security.
In 2012, in response to Facebook cofounder Eduardo Saverin renouncing his citizenship, Senator Casey warned that: “We simply cannot allow the ultra-wealthy to write their own rules.” Today many of those renouncing their citizenship aren’t the ultra-wealthy evading taxes. Many are overseas Americans who find that they can’t do business with FFIs, are not free to make their preferred investments, are hopelessly overburdened by trying to comply with incomprehensible and complex regulations, and are genuinely afraid of the severe consequences if they make a compliance mistake. Yet Bruce Ash, chairman of Republican Overseas Action Inc., concluded that the Obama administration “is building a virtual Berlin Wall to keep overseas Americans from renouncing their citizenship.”
The Obama administration’s response has been to increase the fee imposed by the State Department on those renouncing citizenship by 422% from $450 to $2,350.
Wednesday, December 3, 2014
Saturday, November 29, 2014
NORTHERN NEIGHBORS
by johnscherber |
NORTHERN NEIGHBORS For the United States, the entire nineteenth century was a period of explosive territorial growth. It was launched with considerable foresight by Thomas Jefferson in the Louisiana Purchase of 1803. He was shrewd enough to recognize that Napoleon needed money to finance his ongoing wars, and the Louisiana Territory, which the French […]
johnscherber | November 29, 2014 at 8:38 pm | Tags: 1847, BAD PRESS, CEDED TERRITORY, MEXICAN–AMERICAN WAR | Categories: John Scherber | URL:http://wp.me/p4ta3h-4R
Sunday, November 23, 2014
Mexican Volcano of Fire Spews High Pillar of Ash
Labels:
Explosión del Volcán de Colima,
México,
Travel,
Volcano
Friday, November 21, 2014
Just Junk
The date to list the house is December 1st and we are busy touching up baseboards and doors, kitchen woodwork, deciding what furniture stays for the open house and what we move to storage. When we come back from Mexico and have committed to an apartment, we will decide what specific furniture will be moved to Mexico.
It still looks like a formidable undertaking, however we don't have to move yet, until we actually sell the house. I can tell you right now that we all have too much stuff. Too many books. Too many papers in the office that we can't seem to throw away. Too many knick knacks. Too many kitchen utensils that never get used. I went through one kitchen drawer and found 400 to 500 business cards that are never used; two garlic presses, rubber bands, push pins, a rock with the word "joy" etched into the surface and tape measures galore. I must be addicted to spiral notebooks. They are stashed everywhere, in many different sizes along with pencils with hardened erasures.
It will be great to start over with a clean junk slate. I will vow never to do it again, unless I come across a 19 cent special on 70 sheet spiral notebooks.
Tuesday, November 18, 2014
Interview with Author John Scherber
I just finished a real treat: an interview of John Scherber, a novelist living in San Miguel de Allende, Mexico. I'm in the process of reading everything he has written. When he writes about San Miguel, I like to think he has set the table for our move to the city in 2015.
Mike: Will you tell us a bit about Beyond Terrorism: Survival and what inspired you to write it?
Mike: You seem to have criticism for both political parties in the book. We haven’t read about this aspect of you in your other books. Did you finally just get fed up with the whole government?
John: I have stayed away from politics in the other
books because the subject wasn’t directly germane. But because the epidemic in
this book brings down the government, I felt it was appropriate to suggest that
while we can limp along with this unresponsive system under normal
circumstances, it’s simply not up to handling a serious crisis. Politically,
I’m an independent, a combination of both liberal and conservative, and I don’t
like either party.
Mike: Do you stay away from the subject living in San Miguel?
John: As a noncitizen, I can’t participate in politics in Mexico.
Mike: Do you stay away from the subject living in San Miguel?
John: As a noncitizen, I can’t participate in politics in Mexico.
Mike: Switching to Vanishing Act, why Wisconsin? What kind of research did you do for the book, and what was one of the most interesting things you learned?
John: I set it in Kenniston, WI, which is a fictitious name for St. Paul, where I lived for 25 years. I know the town well, and it has several old Victorian neighborhoods that suited the story.
Mike: My wife, who you will meet in San Miguel, is one quarter Chippawa. I admire writers that take on characters from another era. How did you gain insight into the Chippawas in “Vanishing Act” and their belief in ancient people that can change shape. What was one of your favorite things about writing about those characters?
John: I am fairly ruthless in misusing the cultures of anyone, including mine. Most of the wahkonen material in Vanishing Act was made up, a variant of the shape shifter legends of New Mexico. I like the way these older cultures bounce off the one we come from, and especially how they can reveal how we’re not really that ‘modern’ after all.
Mike: Why Wisconsin? What kind of research did you do for the book, and what was one of the most interesting things you learned?
John: Aside from going to Mesa Verde National Park, I did no research. But I am normally full of obscure and usually quite useless information that I can draw on for projects like this.
Mike: Your other novels take place mostly in San Miguel and Oaxaca in Mexico and the surrounding areas. Was it fun making the switch to the US?
John: I enjoy any change up, and this one was fun. The book started with a short story that was the narrative manuscript of Peter Welsh. I was looking for a horror magazine to publish it, and but when I surveyed the scene, most of them were pretty junky. I thought the story was much better quality than that. Then we came up with the idea of having it be the centerpiece of one of the Paul Zacher mysteries.
Mike : What did you do before becoming a writer? Have you always wanted to write? Will you tell us a little more about that progression?
John: I always wanted to write, and started in high school. In college, at Minnesota, I was in the honorary creative writers’ fraternity with Garrison Keillor. I got a salaried writing job out of college in the mental health field, and wrote two bad novels while I was doing that. I quit writing, thinking I couldn’t waste a year on a book and not have it be any good. I went into designing and building custom furniture, paneled rooms, and restaurant interiors. But I missed writing, and every three or four years I would try to go back to it, but I never could. I was blocked for 37 years. In 2005 the cloud lifted and I started with the first of the mysteries, Twenty Centavos. Now there are twelve.
Mike: You have written extensively about the expat experience in Mexico. How did you end up in San Miguel?
John: We did the beach vacation thing with the kids on school breaks, but we started to wonder what these old colonial cities were like in the interior. We looked at a number of them, and San Miguel seemed right for us. We love Mérida too, but we couldn’t do the climate.
Mike: What’s one of the first things you can remember writing?
John: A ghost story as a high school junior where I was criticized for using the word phantasmagorical.
Mike: One book that is very meaningful to me that you wrote is A WRITER'S NOTEBOOK: Everything I Wish Someone Had Told Me When I was Starting Out. You’ve written how many books since that book was published and is there anything that you could add to that book?
Mike: Who are your heroes?
John: Reading great fiction and nonfiction makes me a better writer. I always like people writing fiction who can keep focused on their job as a teller of stories. That’s why readers stay with us. I regard that as job one. Writers have a strong obligation to their readers that is not always respected. I try hard to never forget about it. My heroes are those writers who stay with it, no matter what, because it’s all about insight and persistence. You need to keep writing all the time because no one can teach it to you as well as the process itself does.
Mike: What are you currently reading?
John: Currently some nonfiction from John Gregory Dunne on the film industry, and I’m rereading The Brothers Karamazov.
Mike: What’s next for you?
John: I have two more mysteries in the works. One is about the Paul Zacher Agency coming up against a local shaman who is able to mess with their minds. The other is set in equestrian country; a terrain full of big egos, championship horses, expensive spreads, and privileged women. In March we’ll traveling to Chiapas to research locations and atmosphere for another Zacher mystery set among the highland Maya. Your readers can find out more about me and my work, as well as get a sample of all my 22 books at my website: www.sanmiguelallendebooks.com
Mike: John this has been a real treat for me. I hope it was enjoyable for you. Thank you. Bev and I will see you in San Miguel in February.
Moving to Mexico
Expat Blog has some great information on planning your move to Mexico:
When it comes to moving large volumes or covering long distances, in Mexico it is recommended to leave it up to the expertise of professional movers who will take charge of the removal process.
Some tips to prepare your move:
Start your moving preparation 3 months in advance
You may have to obtain visas, work permits, vaccination, or cancel services which require a notice period. Make a list of all you need to do. Being well-organized will help the move go more smoothly.
Sort through your belongings
Choose which goods you would like to bring along to Mexico and which ones you prefer to leave behind either with a friend or in a storage unit. Seek advice: it might cost less to buy goods in Mexico instead of bringing over your belongings.
Choose the right moving company
Finding a good moving company is essential to any expatriation project. Independent regulatory bodies like FIDI will help you find reliable moving companies. Internal quality processes, specialized packing materials and a large network will guarantee high standard of quality and service.
Prevent the risk of breakage
Since zero risk does not exist, material damage insurance is highly recommended.
Get Free Quotes from up to 6 Removal Companies and save up to 70% by comparing quotes
Sunday, November 16, 2014
Why Is Mexico Calling?
Zero hedge says it best:
Here are some of the biggest myths we see in the system today:
1. The dollar will continue to be the dominant currency.
This is a total farce. Grumblings grow louder around the world to establish a new non-dollar financial system, and China has taken the lead to make this a reality.
2. The US is still the dominant military power in the world.
If you measure by the quality of trained personnel, this is true. But what good is all of that military power if you can’t afford to do anything with it?
3. The police exist to protect the people.
Wrong again. With so much civil asset forfeiture taking place at the point of a gun(federally funded assault rifles), it’s clear they’re far more concerned about protecting those that maintain the status quo than protecting you.
4. Elections make a difference
Completely false. Most Western governments borrow money to pay interest on the money they’ve already borrowed.
In the US, they spend so much on mandatory entitlements and interest they could eliminate almost the entire government and still not run a balanced budget.
At that level of desperation, it matters not who’s in power.
5. Your bank is safe
Your bank might HAVE a safe. But if you look at objective data, many banks in the West have incredibly thin levels of capital and liquidity—the exact opposite of what a safe bank is supposed to have.
Oh yeah, they’re backed by poorly capitalized deposit insurance funds, which are guaranteed by insolvent governments.
And bear in mind that even if your bank is reasonably capitalized, you are still guaranteed to lose money on a tax adjusted, inflation adjusted basis if you you’re holding your savings there.
6. You have to go to college in order to get ahead
Quite the opposite—going to college in many cases can get you behind; just ask any 36-year old still paying down that $100,000 student loan debt.
The world is a big place full of opportunity. Skills and experience matter more than pieces of paper.
Here’s a better option, especially for young people: head overseas, and become an apprentice to a successful, knowledgeable individual that you respect.
Any young person who thinks that going to college is a good idea should just ask any of their unemployed friends saddled with $100,000 of debt if it was worth it.
7. I saw it on TV so it must be true.
Ufff. The mainstream media exist to paint a distorted version of reality so that people are kept placated, docile and largely clueless about what really goes on in the world.
8. Debt doesn’t matter because we owe it to ourselves
Whoever first said this must have a lot of whips and chains in his closet because he seems to enjoy pain.
If we owe the debt to ‘ourselves,’ that means that we will need to default on ourselves.
This means no more Social Security, Medicare, etc. It means causing the US Federal Reserve to become insolvent and spark a currency crisis. It means causing the collapse of every bank in the country.
Sure, no biggie.
9. The United States is the Land of the Free
Draconian surveillance efforts on its citizens. Punitive taxes, fines and regulation. Rising police state. Telling people what they can or can’t put in their bodies, how to grow their food, who to adore, who to hate. Preventing them to collect their own rainwater and live off the grid.
Labels:
expat,
expats,
financial planning,
Mexico,
Travel
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


.jpg)
